On Thursday, August 27, President Donald Trump signed an executive order renaming Lake Ontario “Lake America” for U.S. federal purposes, directing Interior Secretary Doug Burgum and the federal government to update the official Geographic Names Information System. And I’ll admit that when I first saw the headline, I had to check twice to make sure it wasn’t satire. Nope. It’s real. And it comes right in the middle of an increasingly nasty trade fight between the United States and Canada. Look, I’ve supported Trump because I wanted somebody willing to challenge the political establishment, put America first and stop letting other countries take advantage of us. But this? I’m getting aggravated. We have a serious trade dispute unfolding with one of America’s biggest trading partners, and we’re talking about changing the name of Lake Ontario. Can we please focus on fixing the actual problem?
Yes, Trump Really Just Renamed Lake Ontario “Lake America”
This isn’t something Trump casually floated at a rally. He actually signed the executive order Thursday. Trump said he’d been thinking about the idea for some time and compared it directly to his earlier decision to rename the Gulf of Mexico the Gulf of America. The administration’s argument is that the United States plays an outsized role in protecting and maintaining the Great Lakes. The order says the U.S. Coast Guard provides nine of the 11 icebreaking vessels operating on the Great Lakes and that America has invested nearly $4 billion protecting the Great Lakes freshwater ecosystem during the past decade, while Canada has invested considerably less. Okay. That’s a legitimate issue. If we’re paying far more than Canada, let’s talk about it. Let’s negotiate. Let’s demand that Canada contribute its fair share. But I’m having trouble understanding how changing the name of the lake accomplishes any of that.
Trump Lake America Is Funny — For About Five Minutes
I’ll give Trump this: the man knows how to troll. “Lake America” is funny. You know it’s going to drive the Canadian government crazy, which is probably at least part of the point. Trump even joked Thursday that after renaming the Gulf and now the lake, maybe America needs an ocean next and floated changing the names of the Atlantic or Pacific. Fine. I laughed. Now can we get back to work? Because while cable television spends the next 48 hours arguing about what to call a body of water, American businesses are trying to figure out what a rapidly escalating tariff war with Canada means for their costs, customers and employees. That’s considerably more important than what Google Maps eventually decides to call Lake Ontario.
Because the Canada Trade Fight Just Got Very Real
This isn’t happening in a vacuum. The United States has imposed new 50% tariffs on certain Canadian goods, while Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney has announced retaliatory measures against American imports. Carney has accused Washington of trying to damage major Canadian industries including autos, steel and aluminum. Trump, meanwhile, says Canada has been ripping America off for years and even complained Thursday that the United States effectively helps defend Canada without getting enough in return. Those are serious accusations involving hundreds of billions of dollars in trade between two neighboring economies that have spent decades becoming deeply interconnected. That’s the story. That’s what deserves the president’s attention. Not the name on the lake.
Tariffs Aren’t Funny When You’re the American Paying Them
This is where I’ve increasingly found myself disagreeing with Trump. He talks about tariffs as though Canada gets a bill from Washington and reluctantly mails us a check. That’s not how this works in the real world. American companies importing tariffed products can face the added cost. Sometimes they absorb it and make less money. Sometimes they postpone investments. Sometimes they find another supplier. Sometimes they raise prices. And sometimes employees ultimately feel it. Yes, tariffs can be useful leverage in negotiations. Yes, other countries absolutely engage in unfair trade practices. But a 50% tariff isn’t some harmless negotiating tweet. It can dramatically change the economics of a transaction overnight. If you’re running an American company dependent on Canadian materials, you’re not laughing about Lake America today. You’re trying to figure out what happens to your business tomorrow.
Conservatives Shouldn’t Have to Pretend Everything Trump Does Is Brilliant
And apparently we need to say this again: supporting Donald Trump doesn’t mean surrendering your ability to think. I didn’t vote for a king. I voted for a president whose policies I generally believed were better for America. When he’s right, I’ll say he’s right. When he’s wrong, I’ll say he’s wrong. That’s supposedly what independent conservatives believe. And I’m clearly not alone in thinking this particular stunt is ridiculous. Even commenters on the Fox News story identifying themselves as Trump voters were criticizing the move Thursday, with some calling it silly and asking why the administration was spending time on something like this while Americans have much bigger concerns. Maybe that’s something the White House should pay attention to.
President Trump, Stop Trolling Canada and Make the Deal
Trump’s unpredictability can be enormously valuable in negotiations. Foreign leaders know he might actually do the thing every Washington consultant insists no president would ever do. That creates leverage. I understand it. But leverage is only valuable if you eventually turn it into a victory. If Canada has unfair trade barriers, eliminate them. If Canada isn’t paying enough toward continental defense, negotiate a better arrangement. If Canada isn’t contributing enough to maintaining the Great Lakes, make them contribute more. If American companies are being treated unfairly, get them access to Canadian markets. Bring something home. That’s the win. Changing Lake Ontario to Lake America doesn’t put one additional dollar into an American worker’s paycheck.
I’m Getting Tired of the Distractions
That’s probably what bothers me most about today’s breaking story. Donald Trump has a limited amount of time as president, and America has enormous problems that need fixing. The border. Government spending. Energy. Manufacturing. China. The national debt. Trade. Those are reasons millions of Americans put him back in the White House. Every day spent generating another unnecessary controversy is a day the administration isn’t talking about those accomplishments and priorities. Trump doesn’t need to prove he can dominate the news cycle. He’s been proving that for more than a decade. He needs to prove that his confrontational approach can produce lasting results.
Forget “Lake America.” Fix the Trade Deal.
So yes, the breaking news on August 27, 2026, is that President Trump just renamed Lake Ontario Lake America for U.S. federal purposes. That’s a headline I never expected to type. But here’s the headline I’d much rather be writing a few days from now: TRUMP AND CANADA REACH DEAL, TARIFF WAR ENDS. That’s what America First should look like. Better deals. Stronger American companies. More American jobs. Lower barriers to our products. Fair treatment from our trading partners. Results. If Trump delivers that, I’ll be the first guy applauding him. Until then, I’ve got to call this one exactly what it looks like: a distraction at precisely the moment we don’t need another one.
WE’D LOVE TO HEAR YOUR THOUGHTS! PLEASE COMMENT BELOW.
JIMMY
Find more articles like this at steadfastandloyal.com.
Having trouble? If your comment doesn’t post, submit another comment right after it that says: Jimmy, please approve my comment that didn’t post.
Leave a Reply